The Ultimate Guide to Vegetable Substitutes

A few weeks ago I got some feedback that hurt.

Two of my long term Simple Meal Plans customers left comments saying they found my recipes lacking in vegetable variety.

Too much broccoli and cauliflower!

Asking me to mix it up.

Which got me thinking…

I do use a lot of broccoli and cauliflower and kale in my recipes.

Because that’s what I LOVE to eat.

But just because a recipe calls for a certain veg, doesn’t mean you can’t use something else.

So I’ve made a note to always include alternative veg ideas in my variations.

And I also thought it would be fun to empower you to try a little vegetable substitution on your own…

The Ultimate Guide to Vegetable Substitutes

Leafy Herbs

parsley = mint = coriander (cilantro) = basil = sorrel

Woody Herbs

thyme = rosemary = sage = oregano = lemon grass = lemon thyme = kaffir lime leaves

Leafy Veg

spinach = chard = silverbeet = collard greens = kale = cavolo nero = beet tops = cabbage = bok choy

Root Veg

potato = sweet potato = parsnip = beets = turnip = celeriac = swede = rutabaga = carrots = mushrooms = zucchini = cauliflower

Brassicas

broccoli = broccolini = cauliflower = cabbage = brussels sprouts = chinese broccoli

Crunchy Veg

celery = snow peas = carrots = radish = kohlrabi = cabbage

Green Veg

zucchini = peas = green beans = broad beans = broccoli = asparagus

Summer Veg

tomatoes = red bell peppers (capsicum) = eggplant (aubergine) = zucchini = mushrooms

Aromatic Veg

onions = celery = carrots = garlic

Salad Veg

lettuce = radicchio = rocket (arugula) = baby spinach = baby kale = leafy herbs

EXAMPLE: Beautiful Broccoli with Creamy Tuna Sauce

Lets put this into practice with my Beautiful Broccoli with Creamy Tuna Sauce.

Looking at out substitution guide above, broccoli appears in the Brassicas. So you could substitute any of those vegetables.

Broccoli is also under Green veg. More options there.

On a more general note, you could substitute any cooked veg or legumes.

So maybe some roast eggplant or zucchini or mushrooms? Or saute some leafy veg like kale or spinach and use that instead.

There are always options.

Just trust your instincts.

We’ll turn you into a substitution pro in no time :)

Printable Ingredient Substitute Cheat Sheet!

ingredient substitutes cheat sheet

Enter your email below to join the FREE Stonesoup weekly newsletter and get your printable Ingredient Substitute ‘Cheat Sheet’… It’s FREE!

Can’t see the signup form? Click HERE.

More Ingredient Substitute Ideas

See the The Simple Guide to Ingredient Substitutes.

What about you?

Do you love broccoli and cauliflower? Not so much?
I’d love to hear about your favourite vegetables in the comments below :)

Have fun substituting in the kitchen!

With love,
Jules x

Tags: ,

17 Comments

  • There’s something to be said for vegetables like broccoli, cauliflower and cabbage: it’s harder to get tired of them than some other veggies. When my husband cooks, it’s always broccoli and green beans, unless I happen to suggest something else. A couple of weeks ago I did grocery shopping for him because his hip was hurting too badly. I couldn’t find broccoli, so in a moment of brilliance I bought asparagus, which looked really good. He wasn’t thrilled with my choice, because even though he likes asparagus, we’d had it enough recently that he was tired of it. For us, the bottom line is that the Brassicas are the best. For the record, rutabagas and turnips are also Brassicas (please forgive the botanist in me – it won’t ever go away).

    • I agree Susan – I think the brassicas are much harder to tire of. I love them so much that I was toying with the idea of changing my middle name to brassica. Maybe I should still do it!

  • The cheat sheet is great. I need vegetables while my husband is not too keen on them at all but knows he must have some. So I look for different ways to prepare them (or disguise them). Broccoli is a favourite for me but not for him!! Kale is off the menu for both of us – sorry Jules :), but any other leafy green works for me. Therefore I often end up making soups in order to get more vegetables into the menus. Advice on different sauces or additions to add or methods of cooking would be good.
    Thanks for all the hard work.

  • I -have- been doing this, Jules! You eat way more cabbage than my men will. (grin) Thanks for prompting us with more ideas. Also, I recommend shallots in your aromatics list. Technically leeks fit too, but shallots are seriously delicious.

    • I do love my cabbage Wynne :)
      And yes leeks and shallots could be on the aromatics list.
      I don’t cook with them often though because onion tends to be so much cheaper and just as delicious

  • Lovely list. Thanks. My Dad has diabetes type 2 and can’t eat greens so much even though my mum loves them – especially cabbage! If I cook for them i try to get leeks or green beans in instead.
    For myself I try to vary veg as much as possible and get as many colours in each week- for variety in colour, texture, hot / cold dishes and for all the different goodness they each bring.
    By the way, I also wondered where cucumber would be on your list – crunchy veg? summer veg?
    thanks again

    • Hi Aoibheann!

      I’m curious why your Dad can’t eat greens with his diabetes?

      I have type 2 and greens are a huge huge part of my diet.

      Cucumber could be either crunchy veg or summer veg – depending on the use :)

  • I love broccoli! But I’ve always been one to randomly substitute, and here’s why:

    First, I’m in the opposite hemisphere from you…
    Second, the vast majority of veg that I get comes from the farmer’s market, or gets delivered from the farmer’s market. I get whatever is in season – so it doesn’t matter if I want broccoli when it’s arugula and cucumber season.

  • Jules, you are amazing! What a positive response to negative feedback.

    I was surprised to hear about the comments from your clients complaining about the frequent rotation of certain veggies. Clearly, they haven’t been with you long enough or haven’t been paying attention. I have learned so much from the substitutions lists that you include with all your (free!) online/emailed recipes, and and have become quite an adaptable cook as a result!

    Having the suggestions all in one cheat sheet makes it just that much easier.

    Thanks again for your wonderful service.

  • Hi Jules,
    Like you, my favorite veggies are broccoli and cauliflower! I do try to mix up my choices with parsnips, rutabaga, snow peas, spinach, summer squash, bok choy and onions. I don’t now how to cook without adding onions and garlic to a dish! And lots of avocados although it’s technically a fruit. I sprout my own mung beans and eat tofu often. I use dried beans and lentils weekly to make ahead stews and soups and have a large patch of rhubarb I have been coaxing to grow in our East Tennessee heat. I like most veggies, but turn to those listed most often, with corn, peas, carrots and poblanos making up the second string. I love your recipes and have always subbed what I like, what I have or what I want no matter what the ingredient list indicates. I have always considered recipes as guidelines and usually alter them to make them my own. And as I am a vegetarian I am constantly subbing meat for veggies. Keep up the good work – and keep including broccoli and cauliflower!

    • Thanks Linda!

      I’m wondering what do you do with your rhubarb? I have a thriving patch but don’t use it often because I always think of sweet things when I see it

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *