The Best Simple Coconut Cream Substitutes

Here are my favourite simple coconut cream substitutes for when I run out.

What is Coconut Cream?

It’s a creamy white liquid made from pureeing fresh coconut flesh with water. It’s about 24% fat.

Coconut milk is essentially the same as coconut cream, it’s just had less water added so the fat content is higher around 17%.

The Best Coconut Cream Substitutes

1. Coconut Milk

I rarely buy coconut cream these days because I prefer to just keep one type of coconut product in my pantry and coconut milk is more versatile.

If I come across a recipe calling for coconut cream I just substitute coconut milk 1:1 knowing the results will be lighter. But still delicious.

The only time I wouldn’t use coconut milk is for dessert recipes calling for whipped coconut cream. In those cases I go for option 2.

2. Whipping Cream

If you’re OK with dairy, regular whipping cream is an easy coconut cream substitute. Cream will be slightly higher fat so you may like to dilute the cream with water. For 1 cup cream add 1/4 cup water. But I generally don’t bother.

You won’t get the extra coconutty flavours but in most dishes you won’t notice.

3. Nut Butter or Tahini

If you have almond butter or tahini you can dilute it to make a creamy alternative to coconut cream.

To make 1 can (400g /14oz) coconut cream substitute measure out 150g (5oz) nut butter and 250g (1 US cup) water. Add just a little water to loosen the mixture first. Stir with a whisk, stick blender or food processor. Then add the remaining water.

4. Greek Yoghurt

Greek yoghurt is an excellent coconut cream substitute UNLESS you need to boil the mixture.

Boiling will cause the yoghurt to split into a curdled mess.

You can stabilise the yoghurt by stiring cold yoghurt with corn flour or starch. But I prefer to wait until the end of the cooking to add the yoghurt then just warm it to a gentle simmer so you don’t get curdling.

Even though yoghurt is lower in fat, I’d just use a 1:1 substitution.

5. Canned tomatoes or passata

When coconut cream is providing liquid like a curry or soup, you can take the flavours in a different direction by using a tomato based ingredient.

If you still want some creaminess, a mixture of cream and tomato can be delicious.

For example I’d use 1 cup passata and 2/3 cup cream to make up a can of coconut milk.

6. Home Made Coconut Milk

If you can find desiccated coconut, you can make your own coconut milk. Which avoids the worry about BPA cans.

It won’t be anywhere near as creamy but can be a fun project.

How to Make Coconut Milk

While I have made my own coconut milk (recipe below), the results weren’t as creamy as I’d like which I put down to using a food processor and not having a high powered blender.

And you end up with a heap of pulp which seems wasteful (although my chooks loved it!). There are some excellent ideas on how to use it on The Healthy Chef over here.

makes 2.5 cups
takes 30 minutes
200g (7oz) desiccated shredded coconut
3 cups boiling water

1. Place coconut and boiling water in a glass jug or bowl. Stand for 10 minutes

2. Puree the mixture in a high powered blender (or food processor) for about 10 minutes.

3. Drain the mixture through a fine sieve collecting the milk and discarding the solids (or saving for another use!)

More Ingredient Substitutes

Also see see the Simple Ingredients Substitutes Index.

Have fun in the kitchen!

With love,
Jules x