The Best Simple Fresh Tomato Substitutes

Tomato Substitutes

Looking to avoid lectins or nightshades? Well no tomatoes for you! While it may seem like a massive challenge, there are always options. Here are my favourite simple fresh tomato substitutes.

The Best Fresh Tomato Substitutes

1. Skip it

The easiest and quickest option is to skip the tomato. If you’re cooking a dish with a lot of other ingredients, you probably won’t notice it.

Although if your recipe has tomato in the title, like Tomato Salad, omitting it isn’t going to work.

You need to find another recipe ;) Or try one of the suggestions below.

2. Red Capsicum / Red Bell Peppers

Fresh or grilled red capsicum (bell peppers) can work well instead of tomatoes because they have the beautiful red colour and sweetness that tomatoes provide. Unfortunately they’re also nightshades.

3. Olives

These will add a very different flavour profile, but that may not be a bad thing! Olives provide the lovely savoury umami flavours you also get from tomato. So they will take your dish in a different direction but you won’t be lacking in flavour. Plus they’re not nightshades.

4. Canned Tomatoes

If you are looking for a substitute for fresh tomatoes that still involves tomato, drained canned tomatoes are an excellent option. The flavour is more intense and cooked but you’ll still get the colour and tomatoey goodness. A great option in dishes where the fresh tomato is to be cooked anyway.

5. Cheese

Like the olive suggestion, cheese may seem a bit left field. But both tomato and cheese provide lots of savouy umami flavours to dishes.

Some crumbled feta or shaved parmesan can work to bring your salad or salsa to life so that you won’t miss the tomato.

More Tomato Substitute Ideas

How to Store Tomatoes

Tomatoes are sensitive to chilling injury so don’t refrigerate them. Chilling causes tomatoes to lose their flavour and the texture becomes mealy and dry.

Best to keep at room temperature out of direct sunlight. I store mine in a bowl on the kitchen bench so I remember to use them before they go bad.

If you have some ripe tomatoes that you aren’t going to be able to eat, putting them in the fridge will give you more time to use them. But you’ll sacrifice flavour.

Delicious Tomato Substitutes Flavour Pairings

  • Avocado & Tomato
  • Bacon & Tomato
  • Basil & Tomato
  • Cheese & Tomato
  • Oregano & Tomato
  • Rosemary & Tomato
  • Garlic & Tomato
  • Liver & Tomato

More Ingredient Substitutes

Also see see the Simple Ingredients Substitutes Index.

Have fun in the kitchen!

With love,
Jules x


ps. Like More Ingredient Substitute Ideas?


Join 39,339+ readers of my weekly newsletter and I’ll send you a copy of my printable Ingredient Substitute ‘Cheat Sheet’ and my 102 page eCookbook…

It’s all FREE!

Can’t see the signup form? Click HERE.