The Best Anchovy Substitutes(Including Vegan Options)

Anchovy substitutes

Looking for an anchovy substitute? You’re in the right place! The quick answer: fish sauce is the closest match in sauces, dressings and stews. Use about 1/2 teaspoon fish sauce for each anchovy fillet. For a vegetarian or vegan option, white miso or soy sauce give you the same salty, savory umami hit. And where you need something solid, like on pizza, try olives, capers or bacon. Keep reading for my favorite simple anchovy substitutes, plus which one to use in your recipe.

What Are Anchovies?

Anchovies are very small, deeply flavored oily fish that tend to be polarizing. People either love their intense salty, briny umami hit. Or not.

They’re generally preserved in salt or oil and sold as fillets in jars or tins, or blended into anchovy paste in a tube.

What Do Anchovies Add to a Recipe?

Here’s the secret: when a recipe calls for anchovies in a sauce, you usually can’t taste ‘fish’ at all. Anchovies melt into the dish and add deep, savory umami and salt. That’s why they’re the hidden ingredient in so many dishes, from Caesar salad dressing to pasta sauces, puttanesca and slow-cooked lamb. So when you’re choosing a substitute, think about whether you need that umami, the saltiness, or the actual texture of the fillets.

The Best Anchovy Substitutes

1. Fish Sauce

Fish sauce is essentially fermented liquid anchovies, so it’s the perfect substitute in sauces, dressings, soups and stews. It won’t work on dishes like pizza where you need the anchovies in solid form. Use about 1/2 teaspoon fish sauce for each anchovy fillet, or 1 teaspoon for each teaspoon of anchovy paste. See my fish sauce substitutes if you’re out of that too.

2. Worcestershire Sauce

Worcestershire sauce actually contains anchovies, so it gives you some of the umami complexity. Like fish sauce, it’s a liquid, and it’s also sweeter and tangier, so it’s best in dressings, marinades and Caesar salad. Use about 1 teaspoon per 2 fillets. Here are my Worcestershire sauce substitutes.

3. White Miso

White miso paste is my favorite vegetarian and vegan anchovy substitute. It’s salty, savory and dissolves into sauces just like anchovies. Use about 1 teaspoon of white miso for every 2 anchovy fillets. Brilliant in Caesar dressing!

4. Soy Sauce

Like fish sauce in terms of being a liquid, soy sauce will provide the salt and umami but without the fishiness, so it’s a great option for vegetarians. Use about 1/2 teaspoon per fillet.

5. Seaweed (Nori or Kelp)

For a vegan option that keeps a little of the taste of the sea, crumble a sheet of nori or use a pinch of kelp powder. Seaweed is naturally rich in umami. You’ll need to add salt too.

6. Capers

Capers are salty and briny, and work well in pasta sauces, salads and on pizza. Salted capers are the closest, but capers in brine are fine too. Chop them finely so they melt into the dish. Also see my capers substitutes.

7. Olives

If it’s salty complexity you’re after, olives will dish that up in bucketloads. Kalamata olives or a spoonful of olive tapenade are perfect on pizza, toast and in puttanesca.

8. Parmesan

Another non-fishy source of salt and umami. Grate it into pasta sauces and dressings.

9. Bacon

For pizza and other dishes where you need something solid, bacon will give you salty umami with an extra boost of smokiness – not necessarily a bad thing.

10. Dried Mushrooms or Mushroom Powder

This is taking things in a different direction, but dried shiitake mushrooms or mushroom powder can provide umami to replace your anchovies. You’ll need extra salt.

11. Sardines

If you just don’t have anchovies but don’t mind fish, canned sardines are a good substitute. They’re milder and less salty, so use a little more and season well.

12. Salt

If you’re not a fan of anchovies, the simplest option is to skip them and add a small amount of salt instead. You’ll miss out on the extra umami complexity, but in many dishes it won’t be significant.

How to Make a Vegan Anchovy Paste

Mash 1 tablespoon white miso with 1 teaspoon capers, a pinch of crumbled nori and a few drops of olive oil. Use it 1:1 in place of anchovy paste. It’s also lovely mixed with garlic and spread on toast.

Anchovy Paste vs Anchovy Fillets

They’re interchangeable! Use about 1/2 teaspoon anchovy paste for each anchovy fillet. Anchovy paste is handy because it keeps for ages in the fridge and dissolves instantly. If you have fillets but need paste, just mash them with the back of a fork or chop them finely with a little garlic.

Can I Substitute Anchovy Paste for Fish Sauce?

Yes, in most dishes. Swap them 1:1, mixing the anchovy paste with a few drops of water to loosen it. And it works the other way around too.

Can I Substitute Anchovy Paste for Shrimp Paste?

In a pinch, yes. Both add salty, funky umami, but shrimp paste is much stronger, so start with a small amount of anchovy paste and add more to taste.

Which Substitute Should I Use in My Recipe?

  • Caesar salad dressing – Worcestershire sauce or white miso. Try my Flavor Explosion Caesar Sauce.
  • Pasta sauces and puttanesca – fish sauce, capers or olives.
  • Pizza – olives, capers or bacon.
  • Soups and stews – fish sauce, soy sauce or miso.
  • Anchovy toast or butter – olive tapenade, or miso mashed with butter and garlic.
  • Vegan or vegetarian – white miso, soy sauce, seaweed or capers.

How to Store Anchovies

Unopened tins and jars keep for a long time in the pantry. Once opened, keep anchovy fillets in the fridge in an airtight container, making sure they’re covered in oil, and use within a couple of months. Anchovy paste keeps in the fridge for months after opening.

Anchovy Flavor Pairings

  • Beef & Anchovy
  • Lamb & Anchovy
  • Olive & Anchovy
  • Tomato & Anchovy
  • Garlic & Anchovy
  • Cream & Anchovy
  • Capers & Anchovy
  • Onions & Anchovy

Rainbow chard illustration

Just Wish Dinner Was Easy?

You know the feeling. It’s 6pm, you’re tired and hungry, and the last thing you want to do is work out what to cook. Again.

That’s why I put together my free 5-Ingredient Dinner Ideas. The thinking is done for you, so all that’s left is the easy bit.

  • No more staring into the fridge wondering what to make tonight
  • Just 5 ingredients or less, so shopping is quick and there’s nothing fancy to track down
  • On the table in 15-20 minutes, even if you’re slow in the kitchen
  • Healthy food that actually tastes amazing, enough to satisfy even the biggest food snob
  • Easy swaps for dairy-free, low carb, vegetarian and gluten-free

Join 18,249+ food lovers making dinner easier.

More Ingredient Substitutes

Also see the Simple Ingredient Substitutes Index.

In your corner,

Jules from Stonesoup xx
(Your favourite Australian Food Scientist)
See my bio

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

I’m Jules Clancy, an Australian Food Scientist and certified Health Coach. Stonesoup (est 2005) helps you lose weight without counting or depriving yourself. So you feel good in your clothes.


I know that sounds too good to be true. 

 

Let me show you how.

 

3 Micro Habits to Move the Scale
(without trying) — it’s FREE

Lose weight. Without doing anything hard.