
Looking for a Pedro Ximénez sherry substitute? Or a substitute for sweet PX sherry vinegar? You’re in the right place! The quick answer: for PX sherry (the dessert wine), use Marsala, Madeira, tawny port or a cream sherry. For a non-alcoholic option, try grape juice reduced with a few raisins. For PX vinegar, balsamic vinegar is the best substitute. Keep reading for my favorite simple swaps for both.
What Is Pedro Ximénez (PX) Sherry?
Pedro Ximénez, or ‘PX’, is the sweetest style of sherry, from the south of Spain. It’s made from Pedro Ximénez grapes that are dried in the sun until they’re almost raisins, so the wine is dark, syrupy and intensely sweet, with flavors of figs, dates, raisins, molasses and coffee.
It’s mostly served as a dessert wine, poured over vanilla ice cream (a Spanish classic!) or used in sweet recipes and rich sauces.
What Is PX Vinegar?
PX vinegar is a Spanish sherry vinegar made from Pedro Ximénez sherry. It has a lovely sweet-sour flavor, like a softer, more raisiny balsamic. It’s wonderful in salad dressings, drizzled over roast vegetables, or splashed into pan sauces.
Pedro Ximénez Sherry Substitutes
1. Marsala
Sweet Marsala, the Italian fortified wine, is my best bet. It has a similar rich, caramel, dried-fruit sweetness and works beautifully in desserts and sauces. Substitute 1:1.
2. Madeira
Another fortified wine with a rich, nutty, caramel flavor. Choose a sweeter style like Malmsey (Malvasia). Substitute 1:1.
3. Cream Sherry or Sweet Oloroso
If you can find another sweet sherry, it’s a great match, just a little less sweet and syrupy. Add a teaspoon of honey or brown sugar if you like.
4. Tawny Port
Port is sweet and fortified, with lovely dried fruit flavors. Tawny port is closer to PX than ruby port. Substitute 1:1.
5. Muscat or Other Dessert Wine
A sweet Muscat or other dessert wine has the sweetness, but is lighter in color and flavor.
6. Brandy + Raisin Syrup
Simmer a handful of raisins in a little water until soft, blend, and add a splash of brandy. It’s surprisingly close to PX!
Non-Alcoholic Pedro Ximénez Substitutes
- Grape juice + raisins – my best non-alcoholic substitute. Simmer 1 cup of red grape juice with a small handful of raisins until reduced by half, then strain or blend.
- Date or fig syrup – thinned with a little water. Great over ice cream.
- Prune juice or other dark fruit juice – adds rich dried-fruit flavor.
- Balsamic reduction – in small amounts, for savory dishes.
PX Vinegar Substitutes
(in order of preference)
1. Balsamic Vinegar
With its similar sweet acidity, balsamic is the closest in flavor and acidity to PX vinegar. Substitute 1:1.
2. Sherry Vinegar
The next closest option is regular sherry vinegar, which is made from dry sherry instead of the sweet sherry used in PX vinegar. If you don’t mind the lack of sweetness, you can use sherry vinegar on its own. For a closer match, add a pinch of brown sugar or a little honey. Adding a few currants soaked in the vinegar is another option. Also see my sherry vinegar substitutes.
3. Apple Cider Vinegar
Apple cider vinegar is similar in the intensity of its acidity. But like sherry vinegar, it doesn’t have the sweetness, so adding a little sugar or honey will help. Use 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar plus 1/2 teaspoon honey for each tablespoon of PX vinegar.
4. White or Red Wine Vinegar
Another good substitute. I find most wine vinegars have a harsher, stronger acidity than sherry-based vinegars, so I’d use slightly less. And again, add a pinch of brown sugar or honey to match the sweetness.
5. Lemon or Lime Juice
Citrus juices rely on citric acid, whereas all the vinegars above are acetic acid-based. This means citrus juice has a completely different flavor profile, and none of the sweetness. But if you don’t have any vinegar in the house, or have a vinegar allergy, a squeeze of lemon or lime will provide freshness and bring the other flavors in your dish to life in a similar way.
Types of Sherry Explained
Sherry ranges from bone dry to very sweet:
- Fino and Manzanilla – pale, light and very dry. Lovely chilled.
- Amontillado – aged longer, amber colored, nutty and dry.
- Palo Cortado – rich and complex, between Amontillado and Oloroso.
- Oloroso – dark, rich and nutty. Usually dry.
- Cream sherry – a sweetened blend.
- Pedro Ximénez (PX) – the sweetest of all.
Dry Sherry Substitutes
If your recipe calls for dry sherry (like Fino or Manzanilla) rather than PX, use dry vermouth, a dry white wine such as Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Grigio or Pinot Blanc, or Chinese Shaoxing wine. For a non-alcoholic option, use a tablespoon of apple cider vinegar diluted with a little water or stock.
Can I Use Red Wine Instead of Sherry in Cooking?
Yes, in savory dishes like stews and sauces. It won’t have the nutty, oxidized flavor of sherry, and it’s less sweet than PX, so add a pinch of sugar if you’re replacing a sweet sherry.
What Is the Difference Between Sherry and Cooking Sherry?
Cooking sherry is a cheaper sherry with added salt and preservatives, so it lasts longer once opened. It’s not great for drinking. If you use it as a substitute, reduce the salt in your recipe.
Can I Leave Sherry Out of a Recipe?
Usually, yes. If it’s only a tablespoon or two, you can skip it or replace it with stock or water and a small splash of vinegar. In desserts where PX is a key flavor, it’s worth using one of the substitutes above.
![]()
Just Wish Dinner Was Easy?
You know the feeling. It’s 6pm, you’re tired and hungry, and the last thing you want to do is work out what to cook. Again.
That’s why I put together my free 5-Ingredient Dinner Ideas. The thinking is done for you, so all that’s left is the easy bit.
- No more staring into the fridge wondering what to make tonight
- Just 5 ingredients or less, so shopping is quick and there’s nothing fancy to track down
- On the table in 15-20 minutes, even if you’re slow in the kitchen
- Healthy food that actually tastes amazing, enough to satisfy even the biggest food snob
- Easy swaps for dairy-free, low carb, vegetarian and gluten-free
Join 18,249+ food lovers making dinner easier.
More Tips for Cooking with Vinegar
- The Best Vinegar to Use in Cooking
- How to Make Wine Vinegar
- A Beginner’s Guide to the Art of Seasoning
More Ingredient Substitutes
Also see the Simple Ingredient Substitutes Index.

In your corner,
Jules from Stonesoup xx
(Your favourite Australian Food Scientist)
See my bio