The Best Simple Golden Syrup Substitutes

Golden syrup substitutes

Before I share my favorite golden syrup substitutes, a confession. One of my favorite childhood food memories is dipping a spoon in the golden syrup tin and eating it while my mother was busy baking her ‘syrup biscuits’.

Here in Australia, golden syrup is a pantry staple. It’s the secret to chewy Anzac biscuits, sticky flapjacks and treacle tart. But outside Australia, the UK and New Zealand, that famous green and gold tin can be really hard to find.

The good news is there are plenty of easy swaps you probably already have in your pantry. Here are my favorites, plus which one to use in your recipe.

What is Golden Syrup?

Golden syrup is a thick, amber-colored liquid sweetener made from cane sugar. It has a buttery, caramel flavor that’s milder than molasses and richer than corn syrup. It’s about 75-80% sugar, with the remainder being water.

From a food science perspective, golden syrup is an ‘inverted’ sugar syrup. During processing, some of the sucrose (table sugar) is broken down into glucose and fructose. This stops the syrup from crystallizing, keeps it pourable and helps baked goods stay soft and chewy.

It’s sometimes called ‘light treacle’. The most famous brand is Lyle’s Golden Syrup, which has been made in London since the 1880s.

Golden Syrup vs Corn Syrup

They’re not the same. Corn syrup is made from corn starch and is mostly glucose. Golden syrup is made from cane sugar and contains a mix of sucrose, glucose and fructose. Both stop sugar crystallizing, but golden syrup is sweeter and has a much richer, caramel flavor.

Golden Syrup vs Treacle vs Molasses

Golden syrup, treacle and molasses are all by-products of the sugar-refining process. Golden syrup is the lightest and mildest. Black treacle and molasses are much darker, with a strong, slightly bitter flavor. See my guide to treacle substitutes for more.

The Best Golden Syrup Substitutes

1. Light Corn Syrup or Dark Corn Syrup (best for baking texture)

In the US, corn syrup is the easiest swap to find. It works just like golden syrup in baking, keeping things soft and chewy and stopping sugar crystallizing in candy and caramel. Dark corn syrup is closer in color and flavor, but either works.

How to substitute: 1 for 1. For a richer flavor, add 1/2 teaspoon molasses per cup of light corn syrup.

2. Honey

Honey is about the same thickness and sweetness as golden syrup, so it’s an easy 1 for 1 swap. You’ll get a more floral, complex flavor, which will mostly be a good thing. Honey browns faster, so keep an eye on your baking and cover with foil if needed.

How to substitute: 1 for 1.

3. Maple Syrup

If you prefer not to use refined sugars, pure maple syrup works well. It’s thinner and more expensive than golden syrup, with a more complex flavor, which I think is generally a good thing. Because it’s thinner, it’s best in recipes where the syrup isn’t holding things together, like sauces, glazes, porridge and pancakes.

How to substitute: 1 for 1. In baking, reduce the other liquids in the recipe by a tablespoon or 2.

4. Brown Rice Syrup

Brown rice syrup is thick, mild and slightly nutty, with a similar texture to golden syrup. It’s less sweet, so your baked goods will be a little less sweet too. It’s a great option for flapjacks and muesli bars because it’s so sticky.

How to substitute: 1 for 1. Add a little extra sugar if you like things sweeter.

5. Brown Sugar + Water

Brown sugar is white sugar with some molasses mixed back in, so it has the caramel notes of golden syrup. Dissolving it in water gives you a quick syrup.

How to substitute: for every 1 cup golden syrup, dissolve 1 1/4 cups brown sugar in 1/3 cup hot water. Or by weight, use 3 parts brown sugar to 1 part water.

6. White Sugar + Water

The main job of golden syrup in many recipes is sweetness, so white sugar dissolved in water works from that perspective. You’ll miss out on the caramel flavor, but it generally won’t be a problem.

How to substitute: as for brown sugar above.

7. Coconut Sugar + Water

Coconut sugar is a type of palm sugar made from, you guessed it, coconut trees. It has a brown crumbly texture and a delicious caramel flavor. While it does contain a few more minerals than white sugar, it’s essentially the same nutritionally. Dissolve it in water as for brown sugar.

8. Agave Syrup or Date Syrup

Agave syrup is thinner and sweeter than golden syrup, with a neutral flavor. Date syrup is darker and richer, with a fruity caramel flavor that’s gorgeous in porridge and sticky date desserts.

How to substitute: 1 for 1 for date syrup. Use about 3/4 the amount for agave, as it’s sweeter.

9. Treacle or Molasses

Black treacle and molasses are much darker and more intensely flavored than golden syrup, with deeply caramelized, slightly bitter notes. They wouldn’t be my first choice. But if that’s what you have, use half treacle or molasses and make up the rest with honey, maple syrup or one of the milder options above.

Golden Syrup Substitutes Quick Guide

Substitute For 1 cup golden syrup Best for
Light or dark corn syrup 1 cup Baking, candy, caramel
Honey 1 cup Baking, Anzac biscuits, drizzling
Maple syrup 1 cup (reduce other liquids slightly) Sauces, glazes, pancakes
Brown rice syrup 1 cup Flapjacks, muesli bars
Brown sugar + hot water 1 1/4 cups + 1/3 cup water Baking
Agave syrup 3/4 cup Drinks, drizzling
Date syrup 1 cup Porridge, sticky desserts
Treacle or molasses 1/2 cup + 1/2 cup honey Gingerbread, dark cakes

The Best Sugar-Free Golden Syrup Substitutes

1. Golden Monk Fruit Sweetener + Water

If I want to avoid adding carbs to a dish, a little golden monk fruit sweetener dissolved in water is the closest match to golden syrup. Monk fruit is much sweeter than sugar, so start with less than you think you’ll need and add more to taste.

2. Sugar-Free Syrup

Sugar-free maple-flavored syrups (usually sweetened with allulose or erythritol) are another option for drizzling. They don’t behave like golden syrup in baking, so they’re best for pancakes and porridge.

3. Stevia

Granular stevia is another sugar-free option. It can have an unpleasant aftertaste, but generally you won’t notice if there are lots of other strong flavors in your dish. As with monk fruit, it’s more intense, so start with less.

Which Golden Syrup Substitute Should I Use?

  • Anzac biscuits – honey or light corn syrup. Brown rice syrup also works.
  • Flapjacks and muesli bars – brown rice syrup, honey or corn syrup, as they’re thick enough to bind everything together.
  • Treacle tart – light corn syrup with a little molasses.
  • Sticky puddings and gingerbread – dark corn syrup, date syrup or half molasses and half honey.
  • Drizzling on porridge or pancakes – maple syrup, honey or date syrup.

Questions

Is golden syrup the same as corn syrup?

No. Corn syrup is made from corn and is mostly glucose. Golden syrup is made from cane sugar, so it’s sweeter and has a richer, caramel flavor. But corn syrup is a good substitute in baking.

What is golden syrup called in the US?

There’s no exact American equivalent. The closest is light or dark corn syrup. You can sometimes find Lyle’s Golden Syrup in the international aisle of larger supermarkets, at British food stores or online.

Can I use honey instead of golden syrup?

Yes, honey is a great 1 for 1 substitute. It has a more floral flavor and browns a little faster in the oven.

Can I use maple syrup instead of golden syrup?

Yes. Use the same amount, but because maple syrup is thinner, reduce the other liquids in baking slightly.

Is golden syrup healthier than sugar?

Not really. It’s still mostly sugar, so it’s best enjoyed in moderation as part of a treat.

Does golden syrup go off?

Golden syrup keeps for a very long time in the pantry because it’s so high in sugar. Keep it tightly sealed at room temperature. If it crystallizes, stand the tin in a bowl of warm water for a few minutes. Tip: lightly oil your measuring spoon and the syrup will slide right off!

Rainbow chard illustration

Just Wish Dinner Was Easy?

You know the feeling. It’s 6pm, you’re tired and hungry, and the last thing you want to do is work out what to cook. Again.

That’s why I put together my free 5-Ingredient Dinner Ideas. The thinking is done for you, so all that’s left is the easy bit.

  • No more staring into the fridge wondering what to make tonight
  • Just 5 ingredients or less, so shopping is quick and there’s nothing fancy to track down
  • On the table in 15-20 minutes, even if you’re slow in the kitchen
  • Healthy food that actually tastes amazing, enough to satisfy even the biggest food snob
  • Easy swaps for dairy-free, low carb, vegetarian and gluten-free

Join 18,249+ food lovers making dinner easier.

More Sweetener Substitutes

More Ingredient Substitutes

Also see the Simple Ingredient Substitutes Index.

In your corner,

Jules from Stonesoup xx
(Your favourite Australian Food Scientist)
See my bio

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

I’m Jules Clancy, an Australian Food Scientist and certified Health Coach. Stonesoup (est 2005) helps you lose weight without counting or depriving yourself. So you feel good in your clothes.


I know that sounds too good to be true. 

 

Let me show you how.

 

3 Micro Habits to Move the Scale
(without trying) — it’s FREE

Lose weight. Without doing anything hard.